Donna Kelce May Head to Reality TV Next: Report

Donna Kelce joined the Hallmark family when she briefly appeared in the movie “Holiday Touchdown: A Chiefs Love Story.” New reports suggest that Kelce may be heading back to television again soon, albeit in a very different type of role.

Donna Kelce May Join ‘The Traitors’ Season 4

On June 12, a rumored cast list for “The Traitors” season 4 emerged on the social media site X, formerly Twitter. The list came via a user with the handle @Realitytv_fan, and it quickly spread like wildfire.

According to TV Insider, NBC renewed “The Traitors” for season 4 back in August 2024. The network did a two-season renewal, meaning season 5 is coming down the road as well.

Alan Cumming will return as “The Traitors” host, and filming is expected to be taking place soon. With that, fans have been watching for hints regarding the celebrities tapped to join the upcoming season.

The rumored cast includes a mix of alums from the usual reality television shows, such as “Survivor,” “Big Brother,” and the “Real Housewives” franchise. In addition to a roster filled with reality television alums, Kelce is listed as a rumored contestant.

Others on the list include “The Bachelor” Colton Underwood and “Dancing with the Stars” pro Mark Ballas. Fans may also see DWTS alums Olympic ice skater Johnny Weir and Lisa Rinna compete, along with singer Eric Nam.

The list of rumored season 4 contestants also includes “Love Island” alum Maura Higgins, “Drag Race” alum Monet X Change, and “Real Housewives” personalities Dorinda Medley, Candiace Dillard Bassett, and Porsha Williams.

“Survivor” is rumored to be represented by Rob Cesternino and Yam Yam Arocho. The list has Ian Terry and Tiffany Mitchell showing up to rep “Big Brother.” In addition, “The Amazing Race” alum Natalie Anderson is rumored to be on “The Traitors” season 4.

Fans Are Intrigued By Kelce’s Rumored Casting

News of Kelce’s reported casting generated plenty of reactions across Reddit. In the “New Heights” subreddit, where fans of Travis Kelce and Jason Kelce’s podcast chat, one fan wrote, “The Kelces deserve all of the opportunities coming their way, good for her!”

Fans in the subreddit bantered about whether they thought Kelce would end up being a “Faithful” or a “Traitor” in the game, and several thought she would make a fantastic Traitor.

In the subreddit for “The Traitors,” one fan quipped, “Donna Kelce is a wild pull.”

Another wrote, “Jaw dropped, her plus Johnny Weir makes me absolutely seated. What a fever dream.”

Someone else wrote, “As a fan of the Kelces pre-Taylor [Swift], she is gonna KILL it. I hope she’s a traitor. She gonna run that castle like the Navy for real.”