Michelle Saniei Lally is embracing a fresh start — both on-screen and in her personal life. The Valley star made her reality TV debut this year, stepping into the spotlight just months after separating from husband Jesse Lally.
Following their split in October 2023, days after filming began, the real estate broker quietly started dating financial advisor Aaron Nosler.
Now, as Michelle and Aaron’s romance heats up, fans are asking: Are they still together? Here’s where their relationship stands today — and what’s next for the couple.
How did Michelle and Aaron meet?
During a May 16 Instagram Live, Michelle opened up about the charming way she first crossed paths with Aaron — and it all started with her daughter, Isabella Bunny Lally.
She recalled how they met at a local coffee shop when little Isabella was the first to notice Aaron across the room. “And so they had a little interaction from far away, and I didn’t see it,” Michelle recalled at the time.
“And then I got my coffee and then left, and Aaron and I actually didn’t speak. And then it must’ve been maybe a couple of days or a week later, he saw us again and then it was kind of the same thing. So, Isabella was actually the introduction and it was just very natural.”
Aaron, who joined her on the Instagram Live, called it: “the cutest love story of all time.”
How long have Michelle and Aaron been dating?
Michelle and Aaron went on their first date just a few months after her split from Jesse, though they kept things private for a while.
On April 20, Michelle hinted to fans that she was seeing “someone amazing” during a Q&A on Instagram. By June 17, they made their relationship public when Michelle posted a sweet red carpet photo of them attending “The Bikeriders” premiere. As Michelle put it, her bond with Aaron has been “amazing ever since.”
What does Aaron Nosler do?
According to his Instagram bio, Aaron is a financial advisor and director at Thrivent, a “holistic financial services organization driven by a higher purpose.”
Outside of work, he also runs a brand selling organic white honey and volunteers with Kids Hope USA.
How is Aaron with Michelle’s daughter?
Though Aaron doesn’t have children of his own, he’s already built a great relationship with Michelle’s daughter, Isabella. “Isabella loves [Aaron],” Michelle told The Daily Dish. “He’s great with children and with Isabella, and I couldn’t ask for anything more right now.”
Are things getting serious?
Although the couple has only been dating for a few months, things are already progressing significantly. “It is serious,” Michelle confirmed to The Daily Dish in May.
She added: “I think [given] his age, he’s kind of ready to find a serious relationship, and he knows that I am going through what I am going through, and I didn’t know what was going to happen. I was happy being alone and single. I’m not really dating a bunch of people; I’m not that type of person.”
The couple has already taken the next step and moved in together. Michelle recently revealed that after living on her own for a year, she decided to move into Aaron’s house this spring.
“I lived on my own for a year…and my lease is up. And we had spent a lot of time at Aaron’s house, and we like to make dinners and stuff. So, you know, our relationship is strong, and we want to take it to the next step. So, we thought this is a time to move in together.”
Looking ahead, Michelle is open to the idea of marrying again, although she and Jesse have not yet finalized their divorce. “I mean…the goal is always to one day remarry,” she shared. “And yeah, I would love to be married again one day.”
Comments
Are Aaron & Michelle From ‘The Valley’ Still Together?